Accident Reconstruction Video Evidence vs. Animation
Accident reconstruction video evidence may be an actual film of a collision (the “crash” part) or an animated film created after the event to show one possible explanation of how the events transpired. Knowing this will allow you to create better questions as to what is shown in your claim regarding the video. We at RoadProof assist authorized professionals in finding traffic camera footage, which can serve as a recorded reference for their investigations.
Find Video Footage from RoadProof Today
If you're a law firm or business, sign up today to start downloading video.
Start Your AccountRelated Reading
Traffic Camera Footage for Accident Reconstruction
Understand What You Are Watching
Recorded Footage
Recorded video comes from either a dash cam or traffic cameras. The images captured are what actually happened; however, the video may only show part of the incident.
RoadProof has access to archived traffic camera videos. Your attorney or investigator will have to determine if there is enough footage related to your incident.
Reconstruction Animation
Vehicle positioning, movement, and viewing perspective are all represented and can come from multiple sources such as recorded video, expert opinions, or the reconstructionist’s own assumptions.
Even though an animation appears real, this does not mean it represents the correct event. Ask yourself which aspects of the animation came directly from recorded video and which aspects were created to represent the reconstructionist’s opinions.
Computer Simulation
Simulations use a series of equations to create a probable scenario of the accident. These simulations are typically displayed in the form of animations. However, when evaluating these simulations, one needs to evaluate each individual equation used within the simulation separately.
In order to render an opinion in federal court, experts must have sufficient facts upon which to base their opinions and apply those facts with reliability. A well-designed visual cannot take the place of a solid factual basis.
Ask What Supports the Visual Presentation
When you’re shown a recreation of a collision by an insurance representative, lawyer, or an expert, ask these:
- Is what I am being shown actually recorded footage; is it an edit for better presentation purposes; or was it created on a computer?
- What in this presentation can be confirmed through direct recordings?
- Are there aspects of the scene as depicted in the presentation that cannot be seen with the available cameras or other forms of observation?
- If some of those assumptions are wrong, how would that affect the explanation?
An illustration may have the driver’s head turned toward an approaching vehicle. While that is what the animation depicts, unless there is supporting evidence that establishes that the driver had his head turned toward the approaching vehicle, the video/animation does not establish which way the driver’s head was turned.
Your attorney will decide if separating your recorded observations from the explanations surrounding those observations is important to support your position about a disputed event.
Know How Courtroom Illustrations Differ From Evidence
An animation used solely to describe testimony can be a demonstrative aid. A demonstrative aid is not considered evidence on its own; however, counsel needs to evaluate with the court whether or not it will be useful and/or misleading.
This does not necessarily mean all animations have the same legal status. The attorney should determine what his/her intention for using this animation is and the applicable rules within the jurisdiction where their client’s trial is being held.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does an Animation Replace Missing Camera Footage?
No. An animation can be a visual representation of a forensic engineer’s reconstruction; however, it cannot replace a recorded version of an event where there was no video. Therefore, the credibility of the explanation will depend on the quality and quantity of its support.
Does RoadProof Create Accident Animations?
RoadProof is focused on providing access to historic archived traffic cam footage along with related accident data. For assistance in creating animations or simulations, please contact your attorney or a reconstruction professional.
Last updated Monday, November 2nd, 2026




















